Sunday 21 January 2007

The Truth is Out There

"One of the most common critical mechanisms of hard-line fandom is the rationalisation of shabby prose as 'entertainment'". Discuss.

From a review of Anne McCaffrey's Restoree written in 1969 by M John Harrison, and collected in Parietal Games: Critical Writings by and on M John Harrison, edited by Mark Bould and Michelle Reid. It may be worth noting that Restoree was apparently still in print as late as 1999...

2 comments:

SandChigger said...

Hey, man! It's all about escapism, ya know?

If a piece of writing takes me away from myself for a while...makes me forget about the fact that I'm still prepubescent or functionally illiterate or just dumb as a piece of sandstone...where's the harm in it?!

D'uh!


(A bit over the top, maybe?)

A.R.Yngve said...

People's standards of literary quality change over a lifetime. I could tolerate a lot more typos and Thog-isms when I was 10.